Oskar Josef Gstrein and Gerard Ritsema van Eck ‘Mobile devices as stigmatizing security sensors: The GDPR and a future of crowd-sourced ‘broken windows” (2018) 8(1) International Data Privacy Law 69-85, doi: 10.1093/idpl/ipx024.
Various smartphone apps and services are available which encourage users to report where and when they feel they are in an unsafe or threatening environment. This user generated content may be used to build datasets, which can show areas that are considered ‘bad,’ and to map out ‘safe’ routes through such neighbourhoods. Despite certain advantages, this data inherently carries the danger that streets or neighbourhoods become stigmatized and already existing prejudices might be reinforced. Such stigmas might also result in negative consequences for property values and businesses, causing irreversible damage to certain parts of a municipality. Overcoming such an “evidence-based stigma” — even if based on biased, unreviewed, outdated, or inaccurate data — becomes nearly impossible and raises the question how such data should be managed.